Coffee Makers
Best 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker (2026): 5 Picks Compared
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Specs below come from each product's Amazon listing; we do not test products in person.
For a 5 cup drip coffee maker, the Mr. Coffee Programmable Coffee Maker leads this list: it brews 5 cups with a brew later setting, auto pause and an auto shut-off after two hours. If you want a stainless steel carafe with a 30-minute keep warm feature, the Cuisinart 5-Cup Coffee Maker is the other pick to check.
Starting out? See the main guide: Best Coffee Machine
Top picks at a glance
-
Best OverallMr. Coffee Programmable Coffee Maker 5 Cups9.8 View on Amazon -
9.6 View on Amazon -
Also GreatHamilton Beach 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker9.3 View on Amazon -
9.3 View on Amazon -
9.2 View on Amazon
Compare the specs
Ranked on carafe capacity, programmable, keep-warm setting, auto shutoff, single-serve option from each listing, plus how many buyers have rated it. A dash (—) means we could not confirm that figure from the listing.
| Pick | Carafe capacity | Programmable | Keep-warm setting | Auto shutoff | Single-serve option | Weight | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Mr. Coffee Programmable Coffee Maker 5 Cups | 5 cups | Yes | — | Yes | — | — | — |
| 2. BLACK+DECKER Single-Serve Coffee Maker with 50oz Reservoir | 5 cups | Yes | Yes | — | Yes | — | 2-year |
| 3. Hamilton Beach 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker | 5 cups | Yes | — | Yes | — | — | — |
| 4. Elite Gourmet EHC9420 Automatic 5-Cup Drip Coffee | 5 cups | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| 5. Cuisinart 5-Cup Coffee Maker with Stainless Steel | 5 cups | — | Yes | — | — | 3.97 lb | 3-year |
Mr. Coffee Programmable Coffee Maker 5 Cups
It brews 5 cups with a brew later setting, auto pause, a reusable filter and a two-hour auto shut-off.
- Carafe capacity: 5 cups
- Programmable
- Auto shutoff
Good for
- Buyers who want to set brewing ahead of time
- Buyers who want a reusable filter and water filtration
Skip it if
- You want a carafe larger than 5 cups
- You want an auto shut-off longer than two hours
It has a 25 oz capacity and brews up to two standard 12 oz cups. The carafe measures in ounces for easy pouring, and the maker includes a filtration system with a reusable filter. It draws 650 watts, and the auto pause lets you pour a cup during brewing.
BLACK+DECKER Single-Serve Coffee Maker with 50oz Reservoir
It brews 5 cups with a programmable setting, a keep hot carafe plate and a 2-year warranty.
- Carafe capacity: 5 cups
- Programmable
- Keep-warm setting
- Single-serve option
- 2-year warranty stated
Good for
- Buyers who want coffee kept warm for an hour
- Buyers who want a removable filter basket for cleanup
Skip it if
- You want a carafe larger than 5 cups
- You want a warranty longer than 2 years
It has a reinforced Duralife glass carafe with level markings and a sturdy handle. The removable filter basket takes basket-style paper filters and can go in the dishwasher. The nonstick carafe plate keeps coffee warm for an hour after brewing, and it draws 650 watts.
Hamilton Beach 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker
It brews 5 cups with a programmable clock, a FrontFill reservoir and an auto pause and pour feature.
- Carafe capacity: 5 cups
- Programmable
- Auto shutoff
Good for
- Buyers who want to fill water from the front
- Buyers who want to set brewing up to 24 hours ahead
Skip it if
- You want a carafe larger than 5 cups
- You want a water reservoir larger than 25 oz
It has a FrontFill water reservoir and a swing-out brew basket for easy access under cabinets. It brews up to 5 cups at a time, and the programmable clock sets brewing up to 24 hours ahead. The auto pause stops the flow when you remove the carafe, and it draws 700 watts.
Elite Gourmet EHC9420 Automatic 5-Cup Drip Coffee
It brews 5 cups with a pause and serve feature, a reusable filter and an illuminated on/off switch.
- Carafe capacity: 5 cups
Good for
- Buyers who want a simple on/off switch for brewing
- Buyers who want a reusable filter in a swing-out basket
Skip it if
- You want to brew more than 5 cups at a time
- You want a maker less than 5.3 inches wide
It has a semi-transparent water reservoir with an easy-to-read level indicator. The reusable filter sits in a swing-out basket for easy filling and cleaning. The pause and serve feature lets you pour a cup during brewing, then return the carafe to continue.
Cuisinart 5-Cup Coffee Maker with Stainless Steel
It brews 5 cups with a stainless steel carafe, a removable reservoir and a 30-minute keep warm feature.
- Carafe capacity: 5 cups
- Keep-warm setting
- 3-year warranty stated
Good for
- Buyers who want a stainless steel carafe for pouring
- Buyers who want a charcoal water filter in the reservoir
Skip it if
- You want a carafe larger than 5 cups
- You want a keep warm feature longer than 30 minutes
It has a stainless steel carafe with a dripless pour spout and a Brew Pause feature. The removable water reservoir holds a charcoal water filter and a permanent-style nylon coffee filter. It weighs 3.97 pounds, draws 1100 watts and carries a limited 3-year warranty.
How to choose
Check capacity and cup size
Every pick here brews 5 cups, so the difference is in how each maker counts a cup. The Mr. Coffee brews up to two standard 12 oz cups from its 25 oz capacity, and the Hamilton Beach holds a 25 oz water reservoir. For the Cuisinart, a cup equals approx. 5 oz. Match the stated capacity to how many cups you drink each morning.
Compare programming and pause features
The Mr. Coffee, BLACK+DECKER and Hamilton Beach picks are programmable, so you can set brewing ahead of time. The Hamilton Beach sets brewing up to 24 hours ahead, and the Mr. Coffee shuts off after two hours. The Mr. Coffee, Hamilton Beach, Elite Gourmet and Cuisinart picks let you pause and pour a cup during brewing.
Filters and everyday upkeep
The Mr. Coffee and Cuisinart picks include water filters, and the Mr. Coffee, Elite Gourmet and Cuisinart picks use reusable filters. The BLACK+DECKER uses a removable basket for paper filters, and its basket can go in the dishwasher. Rinse the carafe and filter parts as the maker directs, and wipe the outside after each use.
FAQ
How many cups do these coffee makers brew?
Each pick here brews 5 cups, from the Mr. Coffee and Hamilton Beach 25 oz models to the Cuisinart stainless steel carafe model.
Can I set these coffee makers to brew later?
The Mr. Coffee, BLACK+DECKER and Hamilton Beach picks are programmable, and the Hamilton Beach sets brewing up to 24 hours ahead.
Do these coffee makers have pause and pour?
The Mr. Coffee, Hamilton Beach, Elite Gourmet and Cuisinart picks let you pour a cup during brewing and then resume.
Which pick has the longest warranty here?
The Cuisinart carries a limited 3-year warranty, and the BLACK+DECKER carries a 2-year warranty.
