Toasters
Best Toaster Under $40 (2026): Our 4 Picks Ranked
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Specs below come from each product's Amazon listing; we do not test products in person.
The bella Fits-Anywhere leads this list: one 10-inch long slot that toasts two slices side by side, six shade settings, and a 3.58-inch slim profile for tight counters. The Holstein runner-up adds seven browning settings and a 1-year warranty, while the Brentwood draws 260 watts.
Starting out? See the main guide: Best 2 Slice Toaster
Top picks at a glance
-
Best Overallbella Fits-Anywhere 2-Slice Slim Toaster9.8 View on Amazon -
9.4 View on Amazon -
Also GreatBrentwood TS-260W Toaster Cool Touch9.3 View on Amazon -
Also GreatSimple Deluxe 2-Slice Toaster9.2 View on Amazon
Compare the specs
Ranked on slices, heat settings, auto shutoff, stainless steel from each listing, plus how many buyers have rated it. A dash (—) means we could not confirm that figure from the listing.
| Pick | Slices | Heat settings | Auto shutoff | Stainless steel | Wattage | Weight | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. bella Fits-Anywhere 2-Slice Slim Toaster | 2 slices | — | Yes | Yes | 900 W | 2.5 lb | — |
| 2. Holstein Housewares 2-Slice Toaster with 7 Browning | 2 slices | 7 settings | — | Yes | — | 2.2 lb | 1-year |
| 3. Brentwood TS-260W Toaster Cool Touch | 2 slices | 6 settings | Yes | — | 260 W | — | — |
| 4. Simple Deluxe 2-Slice Toaster | 2 slices | 6 settings | — | Yes | 850 W | 3.4 lb | — |
bella Fits-Anywhere 2-Slice Slim Toaster
One 10-inch long slot, six shade settings, defrost and reheat modes, and a slim 3.58-inch profile fit this search.
- Slices: 2 slices
- Auto shutoff
- Stainless steel
- Wattage: 900 W
Good for
- Buyers who want one long slot for two slices side by side
- Owners of tight counters who want a 3.58-inch profile
Skip it if
- You need more than six shade settings
- You want two separate slots instead of one long slot
It has one extra-wide, 10-inch long slot that holds two slices side by side or thick artisan breads such as bagels, baguettes and Texas-style toasts. Six shade settings with a cancel function set the browning, and defrost and reheat modes are built in. A high-lift lever retrieves smaller slices, and the removable crumb tray slides out for cleaning. It measures 3.58 inches deep and weighs 2.5 lb.
Holstein Housewares 2-Slice Toaster with 7 Browning
Seven browning settings, extra-wide slots, reheat, defrost and cancel functions, plus a 1-year warranty.
- Slices: 2 slices
- Heat settings: 7 settings
- Stainless steel
- 1-year warranty stated
Good for
- Buyers who want seven browning settings for fine control
- Buyers who want reheat, defrost and cancel functions
Skip it if
- You need more than seven browning settings
- You want a toaster under 2.2 lb
It has seven adjustable browning levels, extra-wide slots for bagels, thick artisan bread, waffles and English muffins, and reheat, defrost and cancel functions. A high-rise toast lift with an automatic eject button retrieves small slices. The removable crumb tray makes cleanup quick, and the compact design stores easily. It weighs 2.2 lb and carries a 1-year warranty.
Brentwood TS-260W Toaster Cool Touch
Six settings, auto shutoff and a cool touch exterior in a 2-slice plastic body.
- Slices: 2 slices
- Heat settings: 6 settings
- Auto shutoff
- Wattage: 260 W
Good for
- Buyers who want a cool touch exterior
- Buyers who want six settings with auto shutoff
Skip it if
- You need more than six settings
- You want a stainless steel body instead of plastic
It has six settings, an auto shutoff and a cool touch exterior in a white plastic body. It measures 9.5 by 5.75 by 7 inches and draws 260 watts. It toasts bread and pastries.
Simple Deluxe 2-Slice Toaster
Six shade settings, a 1.5-inch wide slot, a removable crumb tray and 850 watts for thick breads.
- Slices: 2 slices
- Heat settings: 6 settings
- Stainless steel
- Wattage: 850 W
Good for
- Buyers who want a 1.5-inch wide slot for thick bread
- Buyers who want six shade settings and a crumb tray
Skip it if
- You need more than six shade settings
- You want a toaster under 3.4 lb
It has six shade settings and 3 functions, with a 1.5-inch wide slot for waffles and thick artisanal bread. Surround heating warms bread up and down for even browning. The crumb tray is removable, and the matte finish has stainless steel trim. It weighs 3.4 lb and draws 850 watts.
How to choose
Long slot versus two slots
A long slot toasts two slices side by side in one opening, while two-slot toasters give each slice its own slot. The bella has one 10-inch long slot for two slices side by side. The Holstein has extra-wide slots, and the Brentwood and Simple Deluxe are 2-slice toasters.
Browning settings and functions
Browning settings set how dark the toast gets. The Holstein has seven settings, while the bella, Brentwood and Simple Deluxe each have six. Reheat warms toast without extra browning, defrost starts from frozen, and cancel stops toasting. The bella and Holstein both have reheat, defrost and cancel.
Crumb tray and cleanup
A removable crumb tray catches crumbs for quick cleaning. The bella, Holstein and Simple Deluxe each have one. Empty the tray over a bin and wipe the outside after it cools. The bella also has a cord wrap that keeps the countertop neat.
FAQ
How many slices do these toasters make?
Each of the four toasters makes 2 slices: the bella in one 10-inch long slot, and the Holstein, Brentwood and Simple Deluxe as 2-slice toasters.
How many browning settings do these toasters have?
The Holstein has seven browning settings, while the bella, Brentwood and Simple Deluxe each have six settings.
Do these toasters have a crumb tray?
The bella, Holstein and Simple Deluxe each have a removable crumb tray.
What wattages do these toasters draw?
The bella draws 900 watts, the Simple Deluxe draws 850 watts, and the Brentwood draws 260 watts.
