Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Paid link

How-to · Electric Fireplaces

Electric Fireplace vs Oil-Filled Heater

Short answer

An electric fireplace gives heat plus a flame effect, and on the Duraflame, R.W.FLAME and ZAFRO models the flame runs with the heat off, while an oil-filled heater gives heat with no flame display. Choose the fireplace when the flame effect, remote, timer and thermostat matter to the room. Choose the oil-filled heater when heat without a flame display is enough, and compare the maker's coverage figure before you buy.

  1. What the flame effect adds

    An electric fireplace shows flames and glowing logs while it heats, and the flame runs on its own with the heat off on the Duraflame, R.W.FLAME and ZAFRO models. The Duraflame has a 3D flame effect with glowing logs and side viewing windows. The R.W.FLAME has 12 flame and log colors with flame speed control. The ZAFRO has 3D flames with adjustable brightness and a flame-only mode. The DUMOS has 13 flame colors and 13 carbon colors with 6 brightness levels. An oil-filled heater gives heat without a flame display, so the choice turns on whether the flame effect matters to the room.

  2. How to read the coverage figure

    Compare the maker's rated square feet, not the flame count. The Duraflame and the R.W.FLAME are each rated for up to 1,000 sq ft by the maker. The DUMOS is rated for 500 sq ft by the maker. Match that figure to the room the heater will warm, and read the heat settings beside it: the Duraflame runs at 1,500 W, the R.W.FLAME at 500W or 1500W, the ZAFRO at 1000W or 1500W, and the DUMOS at 750W or 1500W. A larger coverage figure suits a larger room.

  3. Controls to check before you buy

    Check the remote, timer and thermostat on the model you pick, since the four models differ. The Duraflame has a remote, a timer and an adjustable thermostat. The R.W.FLAME has a remote, a timer and temperature control, with 2 heat settings. The ZAFRO has an adjustable thermostat, overheat protection and 2 heat settings. The DUMOS has a remote, a 12-hour timer and a thermostat that runs from 50 to 95°F. Pick the controls you will use, and read the maker's manual for how each one works.

  4. Placement and plug-in setup

    These models are freestanding, so set the heater on a flat floor surface where the flame and controls stay easy to reach. The DUMOS also offers wall-mounted and recessed placement, with base legs included for freestanding use. Plug the heater into an outlet the maker's manual allows, and follow the installation manual for placement and clearance. For wiring or mounting work the manual calls for, hire a licensed electrician.

  5. When heat without a flame fits

    An oil-filled heater gives heat without a flame display. It fits a room where the heater stays out of view or where a plain heat source is enough. An electric fireplace fits a room where the flame effect is part of the point, with the heat settings and coverage figure matched to the room. Compare the maker's coverage and heat settings on each model, then pick the one that matches the room.

What you need

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product details come from each Amazon listing; we do not test products in person.

These come from our ranked list Best Electric Fireplace and Heater, which compares them spec by spec.

FAQ

Do electric fireplaces heat a room or only show flames?

Both. Each of these models gives heat and a flame effect, and the flame runs with the heat off on the Duraflame, R.W.FLAME and ZAFRO models. Check the heat settings and the maker's coverage figure on the model you pick.

What coverage figure should I compare?

Compare the maker's rated square feet. The Duraflame and the R.W.FLAME are rated for up to 1,000 sq ft, and the DUMOS is rated for 500 sq ft. Match the figure to the room, and read the heat settings beside it.

Can I run the flame without heat in summer?

Yes, on the models that list it. The Duraflame, R.W.FLAME and ZAFRO each list independent flame and heat controls, so the flame runs with the heat off. The DUMOS lists flame colors and brightness controls with its heat modes.

Do these fireplaces need a remote to change settings?

No. The Duraflame, R.W.FLAME and DUMOS each list a remote, and the DUMOS also lists a touch screen. The ZAFRO lists an adjustable thermostat and heat settings. Read the maker's manual for the controls on the model you pick.

More electric fireplaces how-tos