How-to · Coffee Makers
How Often to Replace a Coffee Maker
Replace a coffee maker when cleaning and descaling no longer fix slow brewing or stale-tasting coffee, or when it leaks or stops working. Watch for the signs instead of a calendar date, and check the warranty before you buy a new one. The Cuisinart model carries a limited 3-year warranty, and the Hamilton Beach and Ninja models carry 1-year warranties.
Watch for the signs
Coffee that tastes stale or bitter after you descale and clean the machine is the first sign. Slow brewing, a machine that stops mid-cycle, water leaking onto the counter, and a cracked carafe are signs too. Buttons that stop responding also point to replacement. When several of these show at once, it is time to shop for a new one.
Clean it first
Descale and clean the machine before you decide it is done. The Cuisinart model has a self-clean cycle that runs at the press of a button and a decalcify indicator that signals when cleaning is due. The Ninja model has a clean setting for descaling at the touch of a button. If slow brewing or stale taste clears up after cleaning, keep the machine.
Check the warranty
Check the warranty before you buy a new machine. The Cuisinart model carries a limited 3-year warranty, and the Hamilton Beach and Ninja models carry 1-year warranties. If the machine still brews but has a fault inside, contact the maker or a repair service instead of opening it yourself.
Match the new one to your routine
Pick the next machine by how you brew. The Hamilton Beach model brews a single cup or a full 12-cup pot, and the Ninja model has a small batch function for 1-4 cups. The Cuisinart model brews a 14-cup pot with a 1-4 cup setting. All four are programmable, and the Cuisinart and Ninja models have adjustable warming plates.
Keep the schedule
There is no calendar date that fits every machine, so watch for the signs and follow the schedule in the maker's manual for cleaning and descaling. A maker schedule beats a calendar guess, so check the manual when you are unsure. When the signs point to replacement, shop for the size and features your routine needs.
What you need
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product details come from each Amazon listing; we do not test products in person.
-
Hamilton Beach 2-Way Programmable Coffee Maker
A 12-cup coffee maker with a single-serve side, a programmable timer, a 2-hour auto shutoff and two separate water reservoirs.
View on Amazon -
Cuisinart PerfecTemp 14-Cup Programmable Drip Coffee Maker
A 14-cup programmable coffee maker with a self-clean cycle, a decalcify indicator that signals when cleaning is due, and a 3-year warranty.
View on Amazon -
BLACK+DECKER 12-Cup Drip Coffee Maker with Vortex
A 12-cup programmable coffee maker with a 2-hour auto shutoff, a Sneak-A-Cup feature and an easy-view water window.
View on Amazon -
Ninja Fresh Brew Coffee Maker
A 12-cup programmable coffee maker with a clean setting for descaling, a 60-oz removable water reservoir and an adjustable warming plate.
View on Amazon
These come from our ranked list Best Coffee Machine, which compares them spec by spec.
FAQ
Can cleaning fix a coffee maker I want to replace?
Sometimes. Descale and clean first, using the clean cycle on the Cuisinart or Ninja model if you have one. If slow brewing or stale taste clears up, keep the machine.
What size coffee maker should I buy next?
Match the carafe to how much you brew. The Cuisinart model brews a 14-cup pot, the Hamilton Beach, BLACK+DECKER and Ninja models brew 12-cup pots, and the Hamilton Beach model also brews a single cup.
Does the warranty cover a coffee maker that stops working?
Check the warranty for your model before you replace it. The Cuisinart model carries a limited 3-year warranty, and the Hamilton Beach and Ninja models carry 1-year warranties. Contact the maker if the fault is inside the machine.





