Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Paid link

How-to · Above Ground Pools

Stock Tank Pool vs Above Ground Pool

Short answer

A stock tank pool is a rigid metal tank holding water, while an above-ground pool is a frame pool with a liner, a filter pump and a ladder. The tank is one fixed piece, and the frame pool comes in set sizes with its own filtration. Pick the tank for a soak and the frame pool for swimming space with its own pump and filter.

  1. What a stock tank pool is

    A stock tank pool starts as a rigid metal tank, the kind made to hold water, set on level ground and filled. There is no frame to snap together and no liner to fit, because the tank itself holds the water. Its size is the tank you buy, so measure the spot first and check that the ground is level and clear of sharp objects.

  2. What an above-ground pool is

    An above-ground pool is a frame pool: metal frame pieces snap or lock together, a liner holds the water, and the set adds a filter pump and a ladder. The Intex set measures 18 ft by 9 ft by 52 in and holds 4,545 gallons, the SunSwell measures 18 ft by 9 ft by 47 in and holds 3,848 gallons, and the Bestway measures 24 ft by 12 ft by 52 in and holds 7,937 gallons. Pick the size that fits the yard and the swimmers it will hold.

  3. Filtration and upkeep

    The Intex set includes a 1,500 GPH sand filter pump, and the sand lasts up to 5 years with regular backwashing. The SunSwell set includes a 300 GPH filter pump with a control valve to filter, drain and infuse water. The Bestway set includes a filter pump and a ChemConnect dispenser that spreads chlorine with the pump. Follow the schedule in the maker's manual for backwashing and water care.

  4. Setup and takedown

    The Intex frame uses an Easy Lock System, and the metal frame pieces snap together with no locking pins or tools needed. The SunSwell frame uses an easy lock system that assembles without hardware, and the pool is ready for water in 60 minutes. The Bestway set has a built-in flow control drain valve that drains by attaching a garden hose with the included adapter. Check the maker's manual for the setup steps and for how to drain and store the pool.

What you need

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product details come from each Amazon listing; we do not test products in person.

These come from our ranked list Best Above Ground Pool, which compares them spec by spec.

FAQ

Which pool is easier to set up?

A stock tank pool is one tank to set down and fill, with no frame or liner to assemble. An above-ground pool takes frame assembly, and the Intex and SunSwell sets use lock systems that snap or lock together without tools or hardware.

Do above-ground pools need a filter pump?

The three pools here each include a filter pump: the Intex set has a 1,500 GPH sand filter pump, the SunSwell set has a 300 GPH filter pump, and the Bestway set has a filter pump with a ChemConnect dispenser.

What size above-ground pool should I get?

Compare the maker's figures: the Intex and SunSwell sets measure 18 ft by 9 ft, and the Bestway measures 24 ft by 12 ft. Wall depth is 52 in on the Intex and Bestway sets and 47 in on the SunSwell set. Measure the yard first, then match the size to the space.

More above ground pools how-tos