How-to · Water Softeners
Water Softener vs Water Filter: How They Differ
A water softener removes hardness minerals, calcium and magnesium, from water by ion exchange through resin, while a water filter removes particles and sediment. Softeners deal with hard water and scale; filters deal with particles and sediment in the water. The products here are water softeners and resin for filling a softener system, with grain capacities from 24,000 to 32,000.
What a softener does
A softener passes water through resin that swaps hardness minerals, calcium and magnesium, for other ions, so the water leaves the resin softer. The resin holds a set amount of hardness, measured in grains: the Aquasure, Tier1 and Superior products are rated at 32,000 grains, and the H&G Lifestyles product is rated at 24,000 grains. When the resin fills up, the system regenerates, flushing the trapped minerals away and recharging the resin.
What a filter does
A filter catches particles as water passes through it, such as sediment, so the water leaves the filter clearer. The Tier1 softener includes a sediment prefilter, and the H&G Lifestyles softener is built for a main water line with 1-inch PVC piping and 2 control valves. A filter does not remove hardness minerals, so it does not soften water; that job belongs to the resin in a softener.
How to choose between them
Start with what is wrong with the water. If the problem is scale on fixtures and appliances, a softener is the tool for the job, and grain capacity tells you how much hardness the resin holds before it regenerates. If the problem is sediment or particles, a filter is the tool for the job. Some homes need one of each, with the filter placed before the softener.
Installation and upkeep
Follow the maker's installation manual, and hire a licensed plumber where the manual says so. The Aquasure softener has a digital control head with a backlit display for setting auto-flush intervals, and the Tier1 softener uses metered regeneration that starts only when household demand calls for it. Check the manual for the schedule, and watch for a filter that looks grey or a tank that smells.
What you need
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product details come from each Amazon listing; we do not test products in person.
-
Aquasure Harmony Series
A 32,000-grain softener for 1-2 bathrooms with a digital metered control head and a 5-year warranty.
View on Amazon -
Tier1 32,000 Grain Water Softener System
A 32,000-grain softener for 3-4 bathroom homes with a ceramic valve, 1 cubic foot of NSF/ANSI 44 certified resin and metered regeneration.
View on Amazon -
Superior Filters Whole House Water Softener System
A cation exchange resin with a 32,000-grain removal capacity, for filling a standard water softener system.
View on Amazon -
H&G Lifestyles Whole House Water Softener
A 24,000-grain softener with NSF-certified resin, 1-inch PVC piping and 2 control valves, rated for 700,000 gallons.
View on Amazon
These come from our ranked list Best Home Water Softener, which compares them spec by spec.
FAQ
Does a water filter soften hard water?
No. A filter catches particles such as sediment, while a softener removes hardness minerals, calcium and magnesium, by ion exchange through resin. If the water is hard, a softener is the tool for the job.
What does grain capacity mean?
Grain capacity is how much hardness the resin holds before the system regenerates. The Aquasure, Tier1 and Superior products are rated at 32,000 grains, and the H&G Lifestyles product is rated at 24,000 grains.
Do I need both a softener and a filter?
It depends on the water. A softener handles hardness and scale, and a filter handles sediment and particles. The Tier1 softener includes a sediment prefilter, so one unit covers both jobs in that system.
How often does a softener regenerate?
Follow the schedule in the maker's manual. The Tier1 softener uses metered regeneration that starts only when household demand calls for it, and the Aquasure softener has a digital control head for setting auto-flush intervals.





