How-to · Water Softeners
Water Softener vs Water Conditioner
A water softener removes calcium and magnesium from the water through ion exchange, so the water measures soft and scale buildup drops. A water conditioner leaves the minerals in the water and changes their form, so they are less likely to stick as scale, but the water still measures hard. The softener needs salt and a drain for regeneration; a conditioner needs neither.
What a water softener does
A softener passes water through resin that swaps calcium and magnesium for sodium through ion exchange. The resin holds the hard minerals, and the softener rinses the resin with salt water during regeneration, sending the minerals to a drain. The Aquasure, Tier1 and Superior systems are rated at 32,000 grains, and the H&G system at 24,000 grains. Because the minerals are removed, the water measures soft, and scale buildup in heaters, dishwashers, washing machines and plumbing drops.
What a water conditioner does
A conditioner does not remove calcium or magnesium. It changes the form of the minerals as water passes through, so they stay in the water but are less likely to stick to pipes and heaters as scale. There is no regeneration cycle, no salt to add, and no drain line. The water still measures hard, because the minerals are still in it, so a conditioner suits a home that wants to limit scale without removing the minerals.
Pros and cons of a softener
The softener's strength is that it takes the hard minerals out, so the water measures soft and scale buildup in appliances and plumbing falls. Its drawbacks are the upkeep: it needs salt, water for regeneration, and a drain, and it takes floor space. The Aquasure is built for 1-2 bathrooms and the Tier1 for 3-4 bathroom homes, so size the system to the home. Regeneration uses water and salt on a schedule set by the maker's control.
Pros and cons of a conditioner
The conditioner's strength is simple upkeep: no salt to buy, no regeneration cycle, and no drain line, so there is less to maintain. Its drawback is that the minerals stay in the water, so a hardness reading does not change, and scale prevention depends on the minerals staying in their changed form. It does not soften the water, so it is not the pick for a home that wants the minerals removed.
How to choose between them
Start with the water: if the goal is water that measures soft and minerals removed, a softener fits. If the goal is to limit scale while keeping the minerals in the water, a conditioner fits. Check the grain rating against the home: 32,000 grains on the Aquasure, Tier1 and Superior systems, and 24,000 grains on the H&G system. Follow the maker's installation manual and hire a licensed plumber where the manual says so.
What you need
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product details come from each Amazon listing; we do not test products in person.
-
Aquasure Harmony Series
A 32,000 grain softener for 1-2 bathrooms, with an automatic digital metered control head and a 5-year warranty.
View on Amazon -
Tier1 32,000 Grain Water Softener System
A 32,000 grain softener for 3-4 bathroom homes, with a ceramic valve, 1 cubic foot of resin and metered regeneration.
View on Amazon -
Superior Filters Whole House Water Softener System
A 32,000 grain whole house softener with digital metered control and high capacity cation exchange resin.
View on Amazon -
H&G Lifestyles Whole House Water Softener
A 24,000 grain softener with NSF certified food grade resin that removes 99.3 percent calcium and 99.5 percent magnesium.
View on Amazon
These come from our ranked list Best Home Water Softener, which compares them spec by spec.
FAQ
Does a water conditioner soften water?
No. A conditioner leaves calcium and magnesium in the water and changes their form, so the water still measures hard. Only a softener removes the minerals.
Does a softener need salt and a drain?
Yes. A softener rinses its resin with salt water during regeneration, and the rinse water goes to a drain. A conditioner needs neither salt nor a drain.
What grain rating do I need?
Check the maker's rating against the size of the home and its water use. The Aquasure, Tier1 and Superior systems are rated at 32,000 grains, and the H&G system at 24,000 grains.





