Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Paid link

How-to · Tankless Water Heaters

Water Heater Types Compared

Short answer

Tankless water heaters heat water on demand instead of storing it in a tank, so the comparison comes down to fuel, flow rate and venting. Two of the four here run on natural gas, one on propane, and one on natural gas or propane, with flow rates from 7 to 10.3 GPM. Condensing and non-condensing models differ in how they handle exhaust heat.

  1. Tankless against tank

    A tankless heater warms water as it flows through the unit, so there is no stored tank of hot water waiting. A tank heater keeps a tank full and reheats it as it cools. Tankless models heat only when a tap opens: the MIZUDO and Westinghouse models heat water only when needed. A tank suits a home that wants hot water held ready; a tankless model suits a home that wants the tank out of the way.

  2. Natural gas or propane

    Fuel is the first split. The Rheem and MIZUDO models run on natural gas, the Westinghouse runs on propane, and the Rinnai runs on natural gas or propane through its Smart Sense gas control system. A home with a natural gas line matches the natural gas models; a home without one needs a propane model and a propane supply. Check which fuel the home has before choosing, and follow the maker's installation manual: the Rinnai and MIZUDO listings recommend professional installation.

  3. Flow rate and BTU input

    Flow rate, in GPM, is the figure to compare for how much hot water the unit supplies at once. The MIZUDO lists 10.3 GPM, the Rinnai lists 10 GPM, the Westinghouse lists 7.9 GPM and the Rheem lists 7 GPM. The Rheem model pairs its 7 GPM with a 35°F temperature rise and 160,000 BTU, while the MIZUDO lists 199,000 BTU and the Westinghouse lists 180,000 BTU. Count the fixtures that run at once — the Rinnai lists 6 fixtures at once, the Westinghouse 3 to 5 fixtures — and match that count to the flow rate.

  4. Condensing, venting and controls

    The Rinnai is the condensing model here; the Rheem and Westinghouse are non-condensing. A condensing model reuses heat from its exhaust, while a non-condensing model vents it. Indoor and outdoor fitting differs too: the Rinnai installs indoors or outdoors, and the Rheem and MIZUDO are indoor models. The Rinnai lists a Quick Flush feature for flushing.

What you need

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product details come from each Amazon listing; we do not test products in person.

These come from our ranked list Best Tankless Water Heater, which compares them spec by spec.

FAQ

What is the difference between condensing and non-condensing water heaters?

A condensing model reuses heat from its exhaust, while a non-condensing model vents it. The Rinnai here is condensing; the Rheem and Westinghouse are non-condensing.

How much hot water does a tankless heater supply at once?

It depends on the flow rate. The MIZUDO lists 10.3 GPM, the Rinnai lists 10 GPM, the Westinghouse lists 7.9 GPM and the Rheem lists 7 GPM.

Can a tankless water heater run on propane?

Yes. The Westinghouse here runs on propane, and the Rinnai runs on natural gas or propane. Check which fuel the home has before choosing.

Do these tankless models need professional installation?

The Rinnai and MIZUDO listings recommend professional installation. Follow the maker's installation manual for the model you choose.

More tankless water heaters how-tos